A SOLDIER'S PERSPECTIVE
THE WEB'S LEADING MILITARY BLOG SINCE 2004
There’s a saying that the greatest peacemakers are the American Soldiers (an all-inclusive term). This is true. Look throughout history and you’ll see that it’s been the American military that has stopped indiscriminate killing and despotism. It is the American military that has defeated those bent on deadly, imperialist ambitions. You can’t defeat violence with kind words and soft gestures. Sometimes, the answer IS war.
I love when people leave comments on my YouTube videos (which ironically have NOTHING to do with war) like this:
you can’t shoot and bomb an ideology away. instead you must make it irrelevant
The next logical question is, “Really? What do you do? Coddle them and send them candy? Do you just them they’re good enough and smart enough and maybe then they’ll change their minds? Do we let them kill our children and tell them, ‘Don’t worry, I can just make more?’ Exactly what do you do with such a violent ideology, genius? How do you make it ‘irrelevant?’”
Okay, maybe you don’t say “genius” because some would be offended at giving them so much credit. The question alone is hilarious enough, but when when these seemingly rhetorical questions are answered is when things get even more absurd.
by helping them find a way to make a life in which dying for Allah isn’t the best option available. it happens by helping them build roads, schools, plant viable crops that they can actually sell for a profit and other such things, not by dropping bombs on their villages. that is, unless you want to make a wasteland of their country and declare that victory
Are the hippies in this country (and around the world) really that clueless about operations in Iraq and Afghanistan? Granted the news does a terrible job at informing the public about what’s really going on in those countries (unless if involves “dropping bombs on villages” – someone’s been listening to the moron John Kerry), but there are plenty of stories out there about building schools, handing out toys and school supplies, building hospitals, helping plant crops, building roads, and on and on and on.
The problem with peaceniks (ie: hippies) is that they wear horseblinders and think that everything can be solved by singing kumbaya and saving water by passing up the shower for days on end. And they do a grave disservice to the men and women in this country who are doing great things to true peace extremists overseas.



LL
I’m buying some of these to give to my dad and sister and myself. I’m sending you one too.
The Kitchen Dispatch
They don’t want to hear it. And when they do, they don’t want to hear that they’re providing much needed medical care to scores of children, to parents who have been maimed or tortured.
And so, I’ve decided that I can’t do much for them –and believe me, many of them are in my own family. Because it’s not my job as a milspouse to change their minds. If they don’t want to listen, they won’t and they’ll die with their bigotry intact.
brat
Wasn’t it a famous American who said something like: “In order to have peace, you must be prepared to wage war”?????
And yes, I agree with Kitchen Dispatch. I usually don’t waste my time trying to change any ‘minds’. Instead, I just continue on sharing what good news I find ( with less than 5 seconds’ research btw.)
Carl Larson
The problem with most soldiers (/Marines/Sailors/Airmen) is that they don’t understand foreign affairs. I was a 12B for 4 years – I know. The officers were a little better, and they’re the ones who call the shots, so I didn’t bother arguing with other overly-testosteroned enlisted guys who’d say dumb things about the hadjis.
Of course you need carrots AND sticks. Anyone who says otherwise is blind. By ignoring a reality-based approach to our foreign affairs (which basically involves trying to see the world through non-Americans’ eyes), you do our important foreign policy issues – and therefore American interests – a disservice. You might try stopping the flag-waving for long enough to read a book on the issues. I would be happy to recommend a few, such as Gen Clark’s Winning Modern Wars or Wright’s The Looming Tower.